skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

From Anthony Rich   9 February 1881

Chappell Croft, | Heene, Worthing.

Feby. 9. 1881.

My dear Mr. Darwin

The sight of your handwriting was a pleasant sight to me. It needed some such stimulus to releive me from the “deficiency of voluntary power” with which I have been contending of late. I take the phrase from the Life of Erasmus Darwin; but it suits me exactly.1 Ever since the late autumn I have been thinking from week to week and day by day that I would write to you, but the good intentions only served for paving of a certain road that no one is particularly desirous to travel. A rather acute phase of a chronic ailment which has tormented me for the last twenty years or more has been the obstacle to the performance of social duties. In other respects I got through and over the severe weather of last month without any greater than the usual discomforts of such a season. But I was obliged to have a fire in my bed room for eight days together, for the first time in my life— All that time I was puzzling myself by endeavouring to guess how it had fared with George D: whether he had got clear away before the snow storm came down—whether he had been caught in it and been blocked on his way to take ship whether his start had been altogether arrested, and he compelled to remain in this ungenial climate till the thaw and milder days set in.2 Your letter clears it all up in the most satisfactory way3—at which I greatly rejoice, and hope that you will not omit to transmit to him my congratulations amidst the first communications that go out from Down. Six weeks ago I bought his friend McLellan’s book on Primitive Marriage—4 For the reason already given it lies still unopened on my table; and the Movement of Plants only yet half through;5 while I have been again travelling for amusement with Miss Bird; this time to the northern island of Japan, amongst a race whom she calls “unmitigated savages, with a splendid physique”, (ahem!) and “bodies covered thickly over with hair, growing longest on the shoulders, from which it falls in flakes like the curls on a retriever’s back”.—6 I hope that she will send you a photograph from one of these originals for the next edition of the Descent of Man.—

Who the Devil’s Mr. Butler?7 When he can say, as you can say, that he has opened out to the knowledge of mankind a new field of Science, and has cultivated it through a life time with marvellous skill and industry, till all the most able men of every country have come to acknowledge the work as one of the greatest and most important discoveries of the age, while the worker is regarded with respect and honour by all who know him—well, when he can say that it will be time enough for you to pay attention to anything he may say.— The compliment you have received from Mr. Gladstone in such a kind and generous way, is proof enough of the estimation in which you are held by one of the first and noblest of men.8 Pity that he can’t know it.—

I have learnt from the Movement of Plants how to account for an appearance which I had long and constantly observed without being able to explain it in any way—why the rows of peas and beans in my garden always made their first start from the earth in little bright yellow arches.9 It is a pleasure to be able to explain to ones own mind an apparent mystery which had attracted observation over and over again while remaining a mystery still. When my gardener was sowing a row of peas last week I took up one of them in my fingers and dropped him into the rill, saying, “ah. when you come up, young fellow, I shall know something more about you than I did when your father was born”.— When I come to read the Chaps. which explain the sleep & movements of leaves, as I am about to do, I shall surely be greatly interested, and acquire knowledge.10 But a thorough book like yours requires for its due appreciation some degree of information & mental calibre more closely allied to your own, than I, alas! can boast—.

I see that Professor Huxley is to succeed Fr. Buckland as Inspector of Fisheries.11 I do not exactly know what the duties of the post may be; but I should fancy that they were pleasant ones, not onerous, and the position one of fair emolument & distinction. Will it induce him, I wonder to live out of London? or in any particular part of the country, inland or by the sea side? If I thought that a cottage like this, (which however might be enlarged by additions) would increase his comfort as a convenient locality for his professional work or as a seaside residence to escape to from time to time and for change air when the London atmosphere or the London season pronounced such a change to be beneficial, I would leave the reversion of the freehold with its 214 acres to him when my hour has struck; and that in the ordinary nature of things cannot be very far off.—12 But you permit me to indulge in the hope that I shall meet you at Worthing sometime in the course of the coming summer; and then we may have a talk. Moreover I wish particularly to show you a Report which we had drawn up three years ago by the City Surveyors, when the old leases were about to expire, respecting the best way of dealing with that property its value for sale, leasing, & amount of rents proper to be asked &c &c &c all of which things it would be well for you to be acquainted with. I look to that visit with interest and, of course, with the greatest of pleasure; and I herewith send my respects and humble petition to Mrs. Darwin that she will not let that promise slip from her own or your memory. After that I shall be able to look on with much equanimity, not to say with a considerable amount of malicious satisfaction, while you are being born bodily away to the Lakes kicking—and screaming—and struggling—like a refractory baby in the arms of its nurse.13

Dear Mr. Darwin | Most truly yours | Anthony Rich.

P.S. My lawn is the Paradise of earth-worms

Footnotes

In his life of his grandfather, CD quoted Erasmus Darwin’s view that the propensity for procrastination exhibited by one of CD’s uncles resulted from ‘defect of voluntary power’ (Erasmus Darwin, p. 75).
The severe blizzard that had struck the southern parts of Britain from 17 to 20 January 1881 had delayed George Howard Darwin’s departure from Dartmouth for a convalescent stay on Madeira (letter from Emma Darwin to G. H. Darwin, 25 January 1881 (DAR 210.3: 1)). For the severity of the weather, see ‘The gale and the snowstorms’, The Times, 20 January 1881, p. 11.
CD’s letter to Rich has not been found.
George Howard Darwin had stayed with John Ferguson McLennan in Algiers in 1879 (Correspondence vol. 27, letter from G. H. Darwin, 3 March 1879). McLennan’s book Primitive marriage had been published in 1865 (McLennan 1865).
Rich’s name is on CD’s presentation list for Movement in plants (Correspondence vol. 28, Appendix IV).
Isabella Lucy Bird visited Japan in 1878; her travel diary, in which she described her encounter with the Ainu people of Sakhalin Island (referring to them as the Aino), was published as Unbeaten tracks in Japan (Bird 1880). Rich’s quotations are not accurate; Bird described the Ainus as ‘handsome savages, with their powerful physique’, and an Ainu ferryman as ‘completely covered with hair, which on his shoulders was wavy like that of a retriever’ (ibid., 2: 83, 136). CD already knew that the Ainu were renowned for their hairiness (see Correspondence vol. 23, letter from W. F. Segrave, 28 May 1875).
In his book Unconscious memory, Samuel Butler had accused Ernst Krause and CD of using his work on the history of evolution without acknowledgement in Erasmus Darwin (Butler 1880, pp. 58–79). Butler’s most recent defence of his position, and his claim that he had been disparaged by Krause and CD, was published in Nature, 5 February 1881, pp. 312–13 (letter to Ernst Krause, 7 February 1881).
CD may have told Rich that the prime minister, William Ewart Gladstone, had immediately recommended that Alfred Russel Wallace receive a civil list pension of £200 a year after receiving a petition sent to him by CD (letter from W. E. Gladstone, 6 January 1881). CD thought Gladstone’s personal letter informing him of the decision was one of the kindest actions he had experienced in his life (letter to W. E. Gladstone, 7 January 1881). The pension was announced in The Times, 22 January 1881, p. 9.
In Movement in plants, pp. 87–8, CD discussed how the epicotyl (the embryonic shoot) of beans and peas breaks through the ground in a strongly arched form.
Chapters 6 and 7 of Movement in plants dealt with sleep and the movement of leaves.
Following Frank Buckland’s death, Thomas Henry Huxley had been appointed inspector of salmon fisheries at a salary of £700 a year (ODNB).
Rich bequeathed his house in Worthing to Huxley in 1891 (ODNB s.v. Huxley, Thomas Henry).
The Darwins did not visit Rich in Worthing until September 1881, following their summer holiday in Patterdale in the Lake District (CD’s ‘Journal’ (Appendix II)).

Bibliography

Bird, Isabella Lucy. 1880. Unbeaten tracks in Japan: an account of travels in the interior, including visits to the aborigines of Yezo and the Shrines of Nikkô and Isé. 2 vols. London: John Murray.

Butler, Samuel. 1880. Unconscious memory: a comparison between the theory of Dr. Ewald Hering, … and the ‘Philosophy of the unconscious’ of Dr. Edward von Hartmann. London: David Bogue.

Erasmus Darwin. By Ernst Krause. Translated from the German by W. S. Dallas, with a preliminary notice by Charles Darwin. London: John Murray. 1879.

McLennan, John Ferguson. 1865. Primitive marriage: an inquiry into the origin of the form of capture in marriage ceremonies. Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black.

Movement in plants: The power of movement in plants. By Charles Darwin. Assisted by Francis Darwin. London: John Murray. 1880.

Summary

Contemptuous of Samuel Butler.

Has read that Huxley will be Inspector of Fisheries.

When CD visits in spring, he will acquaint him with legalities of Worthing house.

Letter details

Letter no.
DCP-LETT-13046
From
Anthony Rich
To
Charles Robert Darwin
Sent from
Worthing
Source of text
DAR 176: 145
Physical description
ALS 8pp

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 13046,” accessed on 19 April 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-13046.xml

letter