I shall be well abused, for as my son Frank says: "you treat man in such a bare-faced manner."
Darwin wrote and received more than 800 letters during 1871, the year in which Descent of man, his controversial first public statement on human evolution was published. The extraordinary number reflects the excitement the book caused. All 2500 copies of the first printing sold immediately, and 5000 more copies were published during the year. Darwin's friend Joseph Dalton Hooker commented, 'I hear that Ladies think it delightful reading, but that it does not do to talk about it, which no doubt promotes the sale.'
Read a detailed account of Darwin's life and work for this year in Darwin's life in letters, 1871: An emptying nest.
I believe Mr Mivart to be a thoroughly honourable man: but he was educated as a lawyer . . .
The zoologist St George Jackson Mivart's critique of the theory of natural selection, On the genesis of species, appeared at almost the same time as Descent. Darwin found his criticisms deeply unfair, and was further distressed by Mivart's hostile review of Descent in the Quarterly Review: 'He makes me the most arrogant, odious beast that ever lived.' Darwin financed the re-publication as a pamphlet of the American mathemetician Chauncey Wright's review of Genesis of species. He also wrote a new chapter for the next edition of On the origin of species to answer the criticisms of Mivart and others.
I care for nothing in the world except. laughing. crying grinning pouting &c. &c
Once Descent was published, Darwin continued his work on Expression of the emotions in man and animals, which he had once hoped to include as a chapter in Descent. By this time he was selecting photographs and woodcuts for inclusion in the book (the photographs were produced by the new heliotype process, which for the first time made a photographically illustrated book relatively affordable), as well as discussing fine details of physiology with colleagues in Britain and Europe.
'I have succeeded in ascertaining the exact weight annually cast up by earth worms over a square yard.
Darwin didn't confine himself to the subject of expression, however. In 1837, he had published a short paper on the action of earthworms; in 1871, he was able to make exact calculations of their effect on the soil. His researches were published in 1881. He also resumed his work on carnivorous plants, feeding poison to Drosera to assess their sensitivity; this work was published in 1877.
It is great news about Henrietta's marriage . . .
Horace, Darwin's youngest son, passed his first examination at Cambridge University in December, and planned to study mathematics and science. In his letter of congratulations, Darwin became philosophical:
I have been speculating last night what makes a man a discoverer of undiscovered things . . . — Many men who are very clever, —much cleverer than discoverers, —never originate anything. As far as I can conjecture, the art consists in habitually searching for the causes or meaning of everything which occurs.
Henrietta Darwin's diary for part of 1871, the year of her marriage.