On critical exchanges at the Linnean Society on natural selection and mimicry.
Roland Trimen's paper on South African mimetic butterflies ["On some remarkable mimetic resemblances among African butterflies", Trans. Linn. Soc. Lond. 26 (1870): 497–523; read 5 Mar 1868].
I am very sorry your letter came back here while I was going to town, or I should have been very pleased to have seen you.
Trimen's paper at the Linnæan was a very good one,—but the only opponents were Andrew Murray and B. Seeman,— the former talked utter nonsense about the ``harmony of nature'' produced by ``polarization'',—alike in ``rocks plants and animals'' &c. &c. &c. And Seeman objected that there was ``Mimicry'' among plants, and that our theory would not explain it. Lubbock answered them both in his best manner.
Pray take your rest, and put my last notes by till you return to Down,—or let your son discover the fallacies in them.
Would you like to see the specimens of pupæ of butterflies whose colours have changed in accordance with the colour of the surrounding objects. They are very curious, and Mr. T. W. Wood who bred them would I am sure be delighted to bring them to show you. His address is, 89, Stanhope Street, Hampstead Road N.W.
Believe me | Yours very faithfully | Alfred R. Wallace—
- f1 5996.f1The year is established by the relationship between this letter and the letter from A. R. Wallace, 1 March 1868.
- f2 5996.f2Wallace was writing from the home of his wife's parents (see Raby 2001, pp. 182--3). CD's letter to Wallace has not been found.
- f3 5996.f3Roland Trimen presented his paper `On some remarkable mimetic analogies among African butterflies' (R. Trimen 1868) at the 5 March 1868 meeting of the Linnean Society. Wallace also refers to Berthold Carl Seemann.
- f4 5996.f4John Lubbock.
- f5 5996.f5In his letter of 1 March 1868, Wallace sent CD a note titled `Sterility of hybrids produced by natural selection' and invited CD to point out to him any fallacy in the argument presented. Wallace refers to George Howard Darwin, who was a mathematician.
- f6 5996.f6Thomas W. Wood.