My dear Sir

It is some score of years since I gathered the Subularia, & once only. The specimens are in advanced bud, but not quite to the flowering (impregnating) point. From recollection, too distant & unclear for reliance, the plants were under water, & where they would still be under water when (or, possibly, if) the pollen would be perfected.— This does not meet your question.¹ There is discrepancy or contradiction in English writers, Smith, Hooker, Lightfoot.² But the following passage seems simple & clear on the point, & is from an author in general very reliable:—

“S. aquatica”— “In piscinis sub aqua, et, aqua æstate exsiccata, ad margines piscinarum”—

“Sub aqua clandestine floret; extra aquam flores parvi albi explicantur”—

Koch Synopsis Floræ Germanicæ et Helveticæ, ed. 2 p. 73.³

Of Limosella aquatica I have probably seen thousands of plants in flower. It grows in hollows, & sides of ponds liable to fluctuations in the level of the water,—so that it is frequently left uncovered, & certainly flowers out of water. From the situations in which it grows, a day or two of heavy rain in autumn will submerge it while in flower, & I have seen it apparently flowering under water, under such circumstances. I do not recall ever having seen it in flower under water in places where it must have remained under water during the growth of its buds up to the actual flowering. In the wet summer of 1843 I found two plants of it, one nearly in flower, the other in flower & past flower, on a spot where they never had been under water, but must have grown on the ground, out of water,—very proby. carried to the spot in a gardener’s watering-can, either as seeds or as very young plants, from a pond some 60 yards distant; a public road, & thick hedge intervening.—

This is a longer answer than you required, I hope not too long. D^r. Dickie, Prof. of Bot^y. in Queen’s College, Belfast, could perhaps answer your question as to the Subularia.⁴ The specimens in my herbarium, the appearance of which most suggests the idea of flowering out of water, are from him, gathered in his former vicinity of Aberdeen.—

Sincerely Yours | Hewett C. Watson