Letter icon
Letter 923

Darwin, C. R. to Ehrenberg, C. G.

29 Oct [1845]

    Summary Add

  • +

    Sends specimens. Asks for information about specimens from Rio Gallegos.

  • +

    What does CGE mean by the term "Fluthgebiete"?

  • +

    French translation gives impression that Ehrenberg attributes Pampas deposit to debacle.

Transcription

Down. Bromley Kent

Oct. 29.—

Dear & highly honoured Sir

I send you a few specimens, through Chevalier Bunsen, which possibly may interest you, as they come from volcanic islands:— I beg you to observe that I do not want any information about them for my own publications.

There is, however, two specimens from the R. Gallegos (100 miles South of the Santa Cruz) which I should be very much obliged, if you could spare time to look at them. I am extremely desirous to know, whether they contain infusoria & resemble those many specimens of the great white infusorio-pumiceous deposit of the coast of Patagonia. If so, these specimens would extend the bed 100 miles; but they interest me especially, because the Officer who has sent me these specimens, has found in this bed numerous bones of great extinct Edentata.

Should you have time to examine this specimen, & would take the trouble to inform me of the result, might I, also, beg you to inform me, what meaning you attach to the word “Fluthgebiete,” which you use, when describing the Pampæan earth which I sent you. A French translation seems to express, that you attribute this deposit of the Pampas to a great flood or debacle; whereas I understood from your letter, that you considered it, as I do, as an estuary deposit.—

I hope you will excuse my troubling you, & believe me dear Sir | Yours with much respect | C. Darwin

    Footnotes Add

  • +
    f1 923.f1
    See letters from B. J. Sulivan, 13 January – 12 February 1845 and 4 July 1845.
  • +
    f2 923.f2
    See letter from C. G. Ehrenberg, 8 April 1845, and Ehrenberg 1845b. His eventual reply to CD's query (letter from C. G. Ehrenberg, 11 March 1846) confirms CD's interpretation as given here. See South America, p. 248 n., where CD corrects the mistranslation of Ehrenberg's term ‘Fluthgebiete’.
Maximized view Print letter