Letter icon
Letter 646

Darwin, C. R. to Jackson, Julian & secretary of R. Geog. Soc.

[28 Jan or 4 Feb 1846]

    Summary Add

  • +

    Enclosed MS by Lieut. W. Christopher misrepresents CD's views. Contains errors in zoology.

Transcription

Down Bromley Kent

Wednesday

My dear Sir

I am very much obliged to your kindness in having sent me the enclosed paper. As it is chiefly directed against my views, it does not become me to make any remarks on what I think of its value. I must, however, protest against several quotations, which anyone wd suppose were from my writings, but which appear to be extracted from some Indian Review.— I may be permitted also to protest against the statement at p. 3, which is absolutely the contrary to what I have imagined & stated in many places in my writings to have been the case.—

I do not believe Mr C. has ever taken the trouble to read my Book or even my own abstract in my Journal: if he has, he has overlooked all my chief data & gives as new in his paper, what he might have found in my work.

As I do not treat of the zoology of coralls, I make free to urge you, before his Paper is published, to get some zoologist to skim it over, as his errors are very great & would be discreditable to any scientific publication to include.— I have marked a few places with pencil for your inspection: I have made this note more critical than I intended, but I hope you will excuse me.

With my renewed thanks | Believe me | Yours sincerely | C. Darwin

Lieut Nelson R. J. has published a theory in Geolog. Trans vol 5. p. 103 on Bermuda, something like this, of Lieut Christophers.

    Footnotes Add

  • +
    f1 646.f1
    The date is based on the reading and review of William Christopher's paper (see nn. 2 and 5, below).
  • +
    f2 646.f2
    William Christopher's paper was read 26 January 1846 at the Royal Geographical Society and submitted to George Bellas Greenough for review (Council Minute Book, Royal Geographical Society). No mention is made in the minutes of CD as a reviewer.
  • +
    f3 646.f3
    Coral reefs.
  • +
    f4 646.f4
    Journal of researches 2d ed., pp. 465–82.
  • +
    f5 646.f5
    The council minutes of 9 February record the decision not to publish the paper.
  • +
    f6 646.f6
    Richard John Nelson. See Nelson 1840.
Maximized view Print letter