Letter icon
Letter 4493

Darwin, C. R. to Trimen, Roland

13 May 1864

    Summary Add

  • +

    Oxalis plants have arrived safely [see 4347].

  • +

    CD regrets his mistake about Disa; will correct it.

  • +

    Thanks RT for his additional facts about Disa.

  • +

    Is recovering slowly from ten months' illness.

  • +

    Asks whether Strelitzia reginae grows in gardens at the Cape. Suspects it must be fertilised by a bird.

Transcription

Down. | Bromley. | Kent. S.E.

May 13 1864

My dear Mr Trimen

I received your letter of Mar 14. some time ago & was fearful that the Oxalis would never arrive, but yesterday to my joy they came safe & alive & are now planted. Please give my sincere thanks to Mr Mac Gibbon & accept them yourself. The plants will be invaluable. My only fear is that each kind has been propagated by offsets from a single stock & if so they will all belong to the same form.

I am sorry for my mistake about the Disa. I have sent an erratum to Linn. Journ.

Thanks for the additional facts about Disa, but I am sure I do not know what I shall ever do with all my wealth of new facts.

I am slowly recovering from my 10 months illness, but I do not know when I shall regain my old modicum of strength. I was pleased to see a nice little review evidently by Mr Bates on your Cape butterflies in that admirable journal the Nat. Hist. Review.

By the way do you see the ``Reader.'' No English newspaper ever before gave half as good resumés of all branches of science: the literature is likewise well treated. I do not know who the Editor is so that my puffing is honest.

Does Strelitzia reginæ grow in any gardens at the Cape? I strongly suspect it must be fertilized by some honey seeking bird; the structure is very curious & this wd be worth investigating

with cordial thanks believe me yours sincerely | Ch. Darwin

    Footnotes Add

  • +
    f1 4493.f1
    Trimen's letter has not been found. It apparently referred to the Oxalis bulbs that Trimen had sent in response to CD's request (see Correspondence vol. 11, letter to Roland Trimen, 25 November [1863]). See also letter from Henry Trimen, 10 May 1864.
  • +
    f2 4493.f2
    James McGibbon was superintendent of the Botanic Garden, Cape Town (R. Desmond 1994). See also McCracken 1997, p. 41.
  • +
    f3 4493.f3
    CD had been investigating dimorphism in Oxalis since 1861 (see Correspondence vols. 9--11). In 1863 CD asked Trimen to look for dimorphic species of Oxalis at the Cape of Good Hope; his interest in Cape specimens increased after Trimen informed him that he had found species of Oxalis that presented three forms (long-styled, short-styled and mid-styled flowers), enclosing drawings and specimens (see Correspondence vol. 11, letter to Roland Trimen, 23 May [1863], and letter from Roland Trimen, 10, 13, and 18 October 1863). CD's notes on Oxalis, including the Cape specimens, are in DAR 109. See also letter to George Bentham, 7 July [1864], and letter to Roland Trimen, 25 November 1864. CD published his observations on dimorphism in Oxalis in Forms of flowers, pp. 169--83; Trimen is acknowledged on p. 169.
  • +
    f4 4493.f4
    CD had worked Trimen's observations and watercolour sketches on the orchid Disa grandiflora into a paper for the Linnean Society (Trimen 1863). See Correspondence vol. 11, letter from Roland Trimen, 16 March 1863, and letter to Roland Trimen, 23 May [1863]. CD refers to an error in his description of the position of the viscid discs of the pollinia in relation to the passages leading to the nectary (see Poulton 1909, p. 227, n. 3). The erratum sent to the Journal of the Linnean Society has not been found.
  • +
    f5 4493.f5
    Trimen's additional observations on Disa grandiflora were presumably sent in his missing letter to CD of 14 March 1864. In Orchids 2d ed., p. 78, CD noted that Trimen had written to him in 1864 with the information that of seventy-eight flowers of this species that he had examined, only twelve had had one or both pollinia removed by insects, and only five had pollen on their stigmas. CD cited this as evidence of the remarkable rarity with which the flowers were visited by insects, despite their large supply of nectar and conspicuous appearance. CD published the additional information he had collected on Disa in `Fertilization of orchids', p. 144 (Collected papers 2: 141), and Orchids 2d ed., pp. 77--8.
  • +
    f6 4493.f6
    The reference is to Henry Walter Bates's anonymous review of the first part of Trimen's descriptive catalogue of South African butterflies (Trimen 1862) in the April 1864 issue of the Natural History Review ([Bates] 1864b). CD annotated the review in his unbound copy of the April 1864 issue in the Darwin Archive--CUL.
  • +
    f7 4493.f7
    CD refers to the Reader, a weekly review of literature, science, and the arts. In 1864 the editor-in-chief was William Fraser Rae. For a discussion of the character of the Reader and the composition of its editorial board, see letter to J. D. Hooker, 26[--7] March [1864] and n. 17.
  • +
    f8 4493.f8
    In Cross and self fertilisation, p. 371 n., CD reported that at the Cape of Good Hope Strelitzia is pollinated by birds of the family Nectariniidae. The Nectariniidae are small birds with long, narrow, curved bills. See also letter to Roland Trimen, 25 November 1864 and n. 7.
Maximized view Print letter