Letter icon
Letter 3608

Darwin, C. R. to Candolle, Alphonse de

17 June [1862]

    Summary Add

  • +

    Is pleased that AdeC is interested in the Primula case ["Dimorphic condition of Primula", Collected papers 2: 45–63]. Is pursuing analogous experiments on other plants and on seedlings raised from the unions.

  • +

    CD's "large work" progresses slowly owing to ill health and his work on Orchids.

  • +

    CD is not surprised that AdeC is unwilling to admit natural selection – "the subject hardly admits of direct proof or evidence. It will be believed in only by those who think that it connects & partly explains several large classes of facts".

  • +

    Hopes AdeC will publish on Quercus

  • +

    and rejoices that he intends to return to the study of geographical distribution. No one can claim to have read AdeC's truly great work on that subject [Géographie botanique (1855)] with more care than CD.

Transcription

Down. | Bromley. | Kent. S.E.

June 17th

My dear Sir

I am extremely much obliged for your kind & very interesting letter. I am pleased that you are interested by the Primula case. Your questions & remarks show that you have gone to the root of the matter. I am now trying various analogous experiments on several plants & on the seedlings raised from the so-called heteromorphic & homomorphic unions; & the results (as far as I have yet seen; for the capsules are gathered, but not yet examined) are interesting; Whenever I publish I will do myself the pleasure of sending you a copy. I am particularly obliged for your information on Alkanna. I have examined the small imperfect flowers of Viola & Oxalis: the case is very different both functionally & structurally from that of Primula.—

You kindly enquire about my larger work; it does make progress, but very slowly owing to my own weak health & ill-health in my family. I have, also, been seduced to publish a small work on the Fertilisation of Orchids, which has taken up nearly ten months. As Mr Bentham & Asa Gray think well of this Book, I have sent by this post a copy for you. One main object has been to show how wonderfully perfect the structure of plants is; another regards close breeding in & in, to which I see you have attended.— I am not at all surprised that you are not willing to admit natural selection: the subject hardly admits of direct proof or evidence. It will be believed in only by those who think that it connects & partly explains several large classes of facts: in the same way opticians admit the undulatory theory of light, though no one can prove the existence of ether or its undulations.—

I hope you will publish on Quercus, & I shall be most grateful for a copy; the genus has long appeared to me preeminently interesting under the point of view to which you refer. I am, also, rejoiced to hear that you have the intention of again returning to Geographical Distribn. I believe few, or no one, can have read your truly great work with more care than I have; & no one can feel more respect & admiration for it & its author.—

Pray believe me, my dear Sir | Yours sincerely & respectfully | Ch. Darwin

    Footnotes Add

  • +
    f1 3608.f1
    Letter from Alphonse de Candolle, 13 June 1862.
  • +
    f2 3608.f2
    In January and February 1862, CD carried out crossing experiments with Primula sinensis using plants raised the previous year from the seed produced by homomorphic and heteromorphic crosses (see letters to J. D. Hooker, 7 March [1862] and n. 10, and 23 June [1862] and n. 4). (By `homomorphic unions', CD meant crosses in which fertilisation was effected by own-form pollen; by `heteromorphic unions', those in which it was effected by different-form pollen.) In April and May, he performed experiments on the common cowslip, P. veris, not only repeating the homomorphic and heteromorphic crosses that he had carried out in 1860 and 1861 (see letter to J. D. Hooker, 23 June [1862] and n. 4), but also investigating the possible prepotency of different-form pollen from a polyanthus (which he considered a variety of the same species) over own-form pollen from a cowslip (see CD's notes from these experiments in DAR 157a: 76--7 and DAR 108: 70). Some of the results of CD's experiments with P. sinensis are recorded in `Illegitimate offspring of dimorphic and trimorphic plants' (a paper not included in Collected papers), which was published in 1869; the results of his experiments with P. veris are recorded in Cross and self fertilisation, p. 28, and `Three forms of Lythrum salicaria', p. 189 (see also Collected papers 2: 121--2). In the letter, CD interlined the phrase `on several plants &' (see Manuscript alterations and comments); he was engaged in crossing experiments with several members of the Melastomataceae, which he believed might exhibit dimorphism (see, for example, letter to George Bentham, 3 February [1862], letters to J. D. Hooker, 9 February [1862], 15 [May 1862], and 30 May [1862], and letters to Asa Gray, 15 March [1862] and 10--20 June [1862]).
  • +
    f3 3608.f3
    See also letters to Daniel Oliver, 12 [April 1862] and 15 April [1862], letter to J. D. Hooker, 30 May [1862], and letter to Asa Gray, 10--20 June [1862].
  • +
    f4 3608.f4
    See letter from Alphonse de Candolle, 13 June 1862 and n. 5. CD and many of his household had had influenza early in the year (see letter to J. D. Hooker, 16 January [1862], and letter to Asa Gray, 22 January [1862]). Horace Darwin became ill during January and had suffered bouts of ill health ever since (see letter to W. E. Darwin, 14 February [1862]). On 12 June, Leonard Darwin was sent home from school suffering from scarlet fever (see letter to W. E. Darwin, 13 [June 1862]). In his `Journal' (see Correspondence vol. 10, Appendix II), CD recorded: `Much time wasted June & July from Leonard's illness'.
  • +
    f5 3608.f5
    See letter from George Bentham, 15 May 1862, and letter from Asa Gray, 18 May 1862. See also letter from J. D. Hooker, [17 May 1862], and letter to Asa Gray, 10--20 June [1862]. Candolle's name is included on CD's presentation list for Orchids (see Correspondence vol. 10, Appendix IV).
  • +
    f6 3608.f6
    See letter from Alphonse de Candolle, 13 June 1862.
  • +
    f7 3608.f7
    See letter from Alphonse de Candolle, 13 June 1862 and n. 10.
  • +
    f8 3608.f8
    A. de Candolle 1855. There is an annotated copy of this work in the Darwin Library--CUL (see Marginalia 1: 106).
Maximized view Print letter