Darwin, C. R. to Murray, Andrew
- +
Thanks for AM's kindness.
- +
CD did not understand him about "prepotency".
- +
With respect to cave animals CD believes that on reflection AM will admit "that on creation doctrine, there has been surprising diversity for such similar habitation".
- +
Has heard from A. von Keyserling who "makes no difficulty about imperfection of Geological Record".
Summary Add
Transcription
Down Bromley Kent
May 5
My dear Sir
I must thank you again for your kindness,—or rather I should say generosity. I find that I did not understand you about ``prepotency''; I thought that you referred to fertility,— with respect to resemblance I fully believe there is often the greatest difference both in crossed species (as has been proved) & in crossed varieties in impressing likeness on offspring. I do not yet understand about marrying hermaphrodite opposites.
It is very kind in you to put in a note about the ``abominable animal''— the case has been struck out in my 2
With respect to the cave animals, reflect on the cave-Rat, the fish Amblyopsis & Astacus in America—the Proteus in caves of Europe, & you will admit that on creation doctrine, there has been surprising diversity for such similar habitations.— Thank you very much for famous list of references.—
I blundered about the Ant-insect— I remembered that some were blind & thought it was Paussus. What a noble thing would natural science be, if all its followers were actuated by your kind & liberal spirit. If ever I feel inclined to write spitefully about an antagonist, I will try & remember & learn a lesson from you, my antagonist.
My dear Sir | Yours very sincerely | Charles Darwin
Since last writing I have heard from capital Geologist Count Keyserling & he makes no difficulty about imperfection of Geological Record.—
- +
- f1 2784.f1
Dated by the relationship to the letter from Andrew Murray, 3 May 1860. - +
- f2 2784.f2
See letter to Andrew Murray, 28 April [1860], and letter from Andrew Murray, 3 May 1860. - +
- f3 2784.f3
CD refers to the bear--whale example given in Origin, p. 184. See the enclosure with the letter to Andrew Murray, 28 April [1860]. - +
- f4 2784.f4
Proteus is the blind cave salamander. - +
- f5 2784.f5
Murray referred to the imperfection of the fossil record as a great difficulty for CD's theory in his review of Origin (Murray 1860a, pp. 281--4). CD refers to Alexandr Andreevich Keyserling. See letters to R. I. Murchison, 1 May [1860], and to Charles Lyell, 4 May [1860].