CD is unsure about JDH's recommendation that he publish a separate "Preliminary Essay". It is unphilosophical to publish without full details.
CD will work for Huxley's admission to Athenaeum.
Down Bromley Kent
My dear Hooker
I am really grateful to you for your two very long letters, which must have
cost you much time. I will just allude to the first; the
several facts you give me are very valuable, especially the marvellous one on Primrose
& cowslip.— At some future time, I
(Many thanks for Forbes map, which I shall pick up when next in London.).—
I have written to Mr Crowe & repeated what you say.
In regard to Huxley; I shd
Now for a more important! subject, viz my own self: I am extremely glad you think well of a separate “Preliminary Essay” i.e. if anything whatever is published; for Lyell seemed rather to doubt on this head; but I cannot bear the idea of begging some Editor & Council to publish & then perhaps to have to apologise humbly for having led them into a scrape. In this one respect I am in the state, which according to a very wise saying of my Father's, is the only fit state for asking advice, viz with my mind firmly made up, & then, as my Father used to say, good advice was very comfortable & it was easy to reject bad advice.— But Heaven knows I am not in this state with respect to publishing at all any preliminary essay. It yet strikes me as quite unphilosophical to publish results without the full details which have led to such results.
It is a melancholy, & I hope not quite true view of your's that facts will prove anything, & are therefore superfluous! But I have rather exaggerated,, I see, your doctrine. I do not fear being tied down to error, i.e. I feel pretty sure I should give up anything false published in the preliminary essay, in my larger work; but I may thus, it is very true, do mischief by spreading error, which as I have often heard you say is much easier spread than corrected. I confess I lean more & more to at least making the attempt & drawing up a sketch & trying to keep my judgment whether to publish open. But I always return to my fixed idea that it is dreadfully unphilosophical to publish without full details. I certainly think my future work in full would profit by hearing what my friends or critics (if reviewed) thought of the outline.—
To anyone but you I shd
Your's truly obliged | Ch. Darwin
Pray thank Mrs
P.S | What you say (for I have just reread your letter) that the Essay might supersede & take away all novelty & value from my future larger Book, is very true; & that would grieve me beyond everything. On the other hand, (again from Lyell's urgent advice) I published a preliminary sketch of Coral Theory & this did neither good nor harm.— I begin most heartily to wish that Lyell had never put this idea of an Essay into my head.
- f1 1874.f1Dated by the relationship to the letter from J. D. Hooker, 7 May 1856, and the letter to J. D. Hooker, 9 May .
- f2 1874.f2Letter from J. D. Hooker, 7 May 1856. The other one, now missing, was a response to the letter to J. D. Hooker, 9 May .
- f3 1874.f3See letter from J. D. Hooker, 7 May 1856.
- f4 1874.f4Burlington House, Piccadilly. The Linnean Society had lobbied the government since November 1854 with the proposal that it should be accommodated in Burlington House along with the Royal Society and the Geological, Astronomical, and Antiquarian Societies. The Linnean's request was granted by the Treasury in a letter, dated 22 May 1856, addressed to the president of the Royal Society and forwarded to Thomas Bell in time for the anniversary meeting on 24 May (Gage and Stearn 1988, pp. 50–1). CD had attended the meeting of the council of the Royal Society on 8 May (Royal Society council minutes).
- f5 1874.f5CD nominated John Richardson for a Royal Medal in June 1856 for his work in natural history and physical geography. Richardson received the medal in November (Royal Society council minutes).
- f6 1874.f6E. Forbes 1856.
- f7 1874.f7See letters to J. D. Hooker, 7 May 1856, n. 13, and 9 May .
- f8 1874.f8Philip de Malpas Grey-Egerton was a member of the Royal Society council with CD.
- f9 1874.f9CD probably refers to P. H. Gosse 1856, a guide to the seaside town of Tenby, which had been published in April 1856 (Publishers' Circular, 15 April 1856, p. 164). CD was planning a visit to Tenby (see letter to W. B. Tegetmeier, 11 May ).
- f10 1874.f10CD had presented this paper, ‘On certain areas of elevation and subsidence in the Pacific and Indian Oceans, as deduced from the study of coral formations’, at a meeting of the Geological Society of London on 31 May 1837 (Collected papers 1: 46–9). He subsequently published Coral reefs in 1842.
- f11 1874.f11See letter from Charles Lyell, 1–2 May 1856. On 14 May, CD followed Lyell's advice and began writing his ‘species sketch’ (‘Journal’; Appendix II).