Red and white campions: JSH regards them as races, not species; a flesh-coloured intermediate exists.
Hitcham | Bildeston | Suffolk
29 June 1855
My dear Darwin,
I have just got home from a 3 days tour among the Clay-pits — where I have been with Fisher (Tutor of Jesus) &
George. I had no idea of the extent to which the workings
have been carried— Many thousands of tons are now raised regularly per annum
& some of the good folks have cleared many thousands of pounds— I am
horrid correction of the Press— I had lately twice
labelled Pollicipes mitella, & yet allowed it to stand as Pilliceps!
Phillip's also saw the proof sheet— Again,
in my Hitcham list, in introducing the dark lines & dimensions on the proof
sheet I have placed one below instead of above ln 53. Ilicanths which are corollifloral.
Hooker has just observed this, tho' he had the proof sheets— It is
very absurd to make such blunders—but they will happen—
———sylvestris Dodaeus =Red or white Campion
α. (red)=diurna, Sibthorpe—rarely hermaphrodite
β. (white)=vespertina, Sibt.—not always dioecious
γ. (flesh) often hermaphrodite—
turns white when transplanted—Engl. Flora
The above is the information in Smiths English Flora I do now regard them as distinct—but races— In Cambridgeshire I never found red— In Suffolk the great majority are red in the hedges— white in the fields— The flesh (or intermediate) not uncommon— It is a question of experiment.
It would be well to try seeds of red in open places, & of white in shady situations— The permanence of colour is often remarkable— I have white
- f1 1706.f1The workings for phosphatic nodules (‘coprolites’) on the Suffolk coast near Felixstowe and Snape (Victoria county history of Suffolk 2: 285–6). Henslow had been instrumental in the discovery of the nodules and recommended their use as an agricultural fertiliser (Correspondence vol. 2, letter to J. S. Henslow, [22 January 1843], n. 1). Henslow visited the ‘crag’ beds on 18 June 1855 (Russell-Gebbett 1977, p. 114).
- f2 1706.f2Francis Fisher, fellow of Jesus College, Cambridge, and Henslow's second son George, who was an undergraduate at Christ's College.
- f3 1706.f3Proofs of Henslow's report on the collections of provincial museums (Henslow 1855b).
- f4 1706.f4John Phillips was also on the committee established by the British Association for the Advancement of Science in 1854 to draw up a report on museums (see Report of the 24th meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science held at Liverpool in 1854, p. xlvi).
- f5 1706.f5J. E. Smith 1824–6, 2: 328–9.
- f6 1706.f6CD cited Henslow's opinion that these are varieties rather than species in Natural selection, p. 404.