Letter icon
Letter 1253

Darwin, C. R. to Hancock, Albany

[21 Sept 1849]

    Summary Add

  • +

    Describes his research on cirripedes.

  • +

    Comments on paper by AH ["Notice of a burrowing barnacle", Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist. 2d ser. 4 (1849): 305–14]. Asks to borrow specimens.

Transcription

Down Farnborough Kent

Sir

I trust to your kindness to forgive a stranger taking the liberty of addressing you. I have been for the last two years (at least such portions of it, as my health allowed me to work in) employed on a monograph, anatomical & systematic, of the Cirripedia; it was consequently with the greatest possible interest that I heard your admirable paper at Birmingham. I made a few remarks on the subject which will perhaps appear in the Athenæum. In S. America I collected an allied form, parasitic in the Concholepas & which probably will be included in the same order with your's, but which I think must certainly form a very distinct family.

I was very glad to hear from Mr Taylor that your Paper will appear in the Annals & then I shall be able to study it.— I have no sort of pretension to claim any favour from you, but if you could at any time spare me one or two specimens in the shell, preserved in Spirits, it would be the most material kindness.— I would pledge my honour not to publish anything so as to interfere with any further researches you might choose to make on the species.— No one can be aware better than yourself after your excellent labours on the Mollusca, that when one is employed on a Monograph, trifling points are found to be of interest, which are known to be so only to those employed on the class & it is on this grounds that I shd so much like to dissect a specimen of your genus.— I have now dissected species of all the genera of the Cirripedia, & have nearly finished the systematic part of the Pedunculata, but yet from the extreme slowness of rate, at which my health allows me to work, my monograph will not appear for one or two years, so that I could not encroach on anything which you might choose to publish further on the subject.

I trust that the great interest, which I have felt in your interesting discovery, will make you forgive my taking the liberty of asking you so great a favour as that contained in this letter.

I beg to remain. | With much respect | Yours faithfully | C. Darwin
To | A. Hancock Esqre

    Footnotes Add

  • +
    f1 1253.f1
    CD returned to Down on 21 September 1849 (‘Journal’; Correspondence vol. 4, Appendix I).
  • +
    f2 1253.f2
    The paper, on Hancock's discovery of a new genus of boring Cirripedia, though read to section D (natural history, including physiology) at the meeting, was not published in the Report of the 19th meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science held at Birmingham in 1849 (see addenda, p. 125). It was published under a slightly different title in Annals and Magazine of Natural History (A. Hancock 1849b).
  • +
    f3 1253.f3
    Athenæum, no. 1143, 22 September 1849, p. 966. The report is reprinted in Collected papers 1: 250–1. See also letter to J. D. Dana, 24 February [1850].
  • +
    f4 1253.f4
    CD refers to the specimen he originally named Arthrobalanus and later Cryptophialus minutus. Like Hancock's Alcippe, CD's barnacle was also a parasite which had the power to bore, and hence he suspected the two were allied. In his comments on Hancock's paper, CD compared Arthrobalanus to Alcippe: ‘Its main affinity to the genus described by Mr. Hancock lies in the number and position of the cirri and the great developement of the labrum:— the metamorphosis and organs of generation appear to be considerably different.’ (Collected papers 1: 250).
  • +
    f5 1253.f5
    Richard Taylor, editor and publisher of Annals and Magazine of Natural History.
  • +
    f6 1253.f6
    A. Hancock 1849b. CD's annotated copy is in the Darwin Library–CUL.
  • +
    f7 1253.f7
    Alder and Hancock 1845–55, issued in parts by the Ray Society. CD's annotated copy is in the Darwin Library–CUL.
  • +
    f8 1253.f8
    The first volume of Living Cirripedia was published in 1851. It is devoted to the Lepadidae or pedunculated Cirripedia, but the genus Alcippe is not described therein. CD did not suspect that Alcippe could be included among the Lepadidae until he examined it in 1853 (see Living Cirripedia (1854): 526–9, and the correspondence between CD and Hancock early in 1853, Correspondence vol. 5).
Maximized view Print letter