skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

From Fritz Müller   20 February 1878

Joinville. Sa Catharina, Brazil,

Feb. 20th. 1878.

My dear Sir,

I have just come down a few hours ago from our highlands where I visited a new German settlement São Bento situated on some small tributaries of the Rio Negro.1 The white cleistogamic Viola is there extremely common & produces numerous normal & subterraneous flowers & fruits at the same time; in a few weeks there would have been plenty of seeds, but now almost all of them were as yet unripe so that I can send you but very few.2

In São Bento I have spent my time principally in catching butterflies of which I have made a rich harvest.3

On the Itajahy we have 3 sp. of Eueides, viz. E. Pavana, Isabella, & Aciphera; all of them are rare & E. Pavana extremely so. E. Pavana resembles closely to Acræa Thalia, E. Isabella to Mechanitis Lysimnia & Heliconius Eucrates, E. Aciphera to Colænis Julia.4 I formerly thought that the 3 rare sp. of Eueides mimicked the 3 common sp. of Acræa, Mechanitis & Colænis.

Afterwards, after finding that the several sp. of Eueides possess a very strong & repugnant odour I had become somewhat doubtful; & now at São Bento I found that Eueides Aciphera was extremely common, so common indeed that repeatedly I caught at once as many as 8 specimens in the net; whereas Colænis Julia was so rare that I have seen but 2 or 3 specimens at all.5

Thus judging by their relative frequency an observer on the Itajahy might consider Eueides Aciphera as a mimicker of C. Julia & an observer at São Bento C. Julia as a mimicker of E. Aciphera!

There was at São Bento a Papilio (allied to P. Grayi) the wings of the ♂ of which exhaled a strong & so delicious an odour that one might use it as indeed we did as a nosegay.6 I observed on this excursion, some other interesting cases of odoriferous butterflies. Thus I found that the two retractile pencils at the end of the abdomen of Lycorea ♂ exhude a strong odour repugnant to human noses but no doubt agreeable to the ♀s of that sp.7

&c &c | (Signed) | Fritz Müller.

Footnotes

São Bento do Sul, a settlement in north-eastern Santa Catarina, Brazil, was founded in 1873 (Baily and Míguez 2003, p. 231). Müller had visited the area from 8 to 18 February 1878 (Möller ed. 1915–21, 2: 372–6).
Müller had found this species on an earlier expedition to the highlands of Santa Catarina and had written to CD that he hoped to be able to send him seeds in a few months (see Correspondence vol. 25, letter from Fritz Müller, 19 October 1877 and n. 6). The species he observed was probably Viola subdimidiata, a native of this region (for more on its floral biology, see Freitas and Sazima 2003).
Müller described several genera of Lepidoptera found in the region of São Bento in a letter to his brother, Hermann, of 9 March 1878 (Möller ed. 1915–21, 2: 372–6).
Müller’s homestead was beside the Itajaí Açu river about twenty-five miles inland from the town of Itajahy, and was later incorporated within the town of Blumenau. Eueides is a butterfly genus in the subfamily Heliconiinae; E. pavana is the pavana longwing; E. isabella is the Isabella longwing; and E. aliphera (a synonym of Heliconius aliphera; ‘Aciphera’ is a spelling error) is the aliphera longwing. Acraea thalia is a synonym of Actinote thalia (for more on interspecific mimicry in Actinote and the identification of Müller’s published specimens of A. thalia, see Francini and Penz 2006). Mechanitis lysimnia is the lysimnia tigerwing; Heliconius eucrate is a synonym of H. ethilla; Colaenis julia is a synonym of Dryas iulia (Julia longwing); Müller noted the close resemblance between these species in F. Müller 1878, p. 222.
The Eueides species mentioned have ranges whose southern limit barely reaches the area of Müller’s home; they are more common further north. Although Colaenis julia is widespread in the Brazilian rainforest, it is more common in disturbed open habitats.
Müller mentioned the pleasant odour produced by the wings of males of Papilio scamander or Papilio grayi (a synonym) in F. Müller 1878, p. 219.
The odour produced by the hair pencils in males of species of Lycorea was described in F. Müller 1878, p. 212.

Bibliography

Correspondence: The correspondence of Charles Darwin. Edited by Frederick Burkhardt et al. 29 vols to date. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 1985–.

Summary

Reports butterfly species that apparently mimic each other and gives details of some odoriferous species.

[Letter copied in Raphael Meldola’s hand from original sent to Meldola with 11449.]

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 11368,” accessed on 24 April 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-11368.xml

letter