skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

From Francis Darwin    [21 October 1881]1

Friday

My dear Father

I am very sorry to hear about Wiesner   I read that experiment about transmission of heliotropism just before I went away, I’m afraid it is horribly conclusive;2 I didnt say anything about it to you as I thought possibly you might get stuck before you got there. Nature has sent me the book to review; I want to know what you think about it doing it, it might be an opportunity of saying anything we want to say about it; but I am rather inclined to refuse, anyhow I can’t do it for a long time, that is if I write a review signed with my name.3 I might write rather a short notice anonymously without so much care as a signed article would want.

I will see what the untranslateable bit about the seedlings at different distances is.

That sounds an extraordinary case of F. Müller4

I suppose you got the Pinguicula5

I have sent off a salmon which I killed yesterday & which is in better condition than the first one. I had fished all day and only got a 3 pound grilse & then killed this one just as I was obliged to rush off for the train.

Yr affec son | F. D

Footnotes

The date is established by the relationship between this letter and the letters to Francis Darwin, 17 October 1881 and 22 [October 1881]. In 1881, the Friday before 22 October was 21 October.
See letter to Francis Darwin, 17 October 1881 and n. 5. CD was reading Julius Wiesner’s book (Wiesner 1881), which challenged CD’s explanation of heliotropism in Movement in plants.
In the event, Francis did not write a typical review of Wiesner 1881, but rather a detailed reply to specific criticisms made in the book (F. Darwin 1882).
Pinguicula is the genus of butterwort.

Bibliography

Darwin, Francis. 1882. Prof. Wiesner on ‘The power of movement in plants’. Nature, 20 April 1882, pp. 579–82, 27 April 1882, pp. 597–601.

Movement in plants: The power of movement in plants. By Charles Darwin. Assisted by Francis Darwin. London: John Murray. 1880.

Wiesner, Julius. 1881. Das Bewegungsvermögen der Pflanzen. Eine kritische Studie über das gleichnamige Werk von Charles Darwin nebst neuen Untersuchungen. Vienna: Alfred Hölder.

Summary

Commiserates on news of Wiesner and experiment on transmission of heliotropism. Asks whether he should review book for Nature.

Letter details

Letter no.
DCP-LETT-13474F
From
Francis Darwin
To
Charles Robert Darwin
Source of text
DAR 274.1: 69
Physical description
ALS

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 13474F,” accessed on 19 April 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-13474F.xml

letter