skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

To Auguste Forel   15 October 1874

Down, Beckenham, Kent.

Oct 15th 1874

My dear Sir

I have now read the whole of your admirable work & seldom in my life have I been more interested by any book.1 There are so many interesting facts & discussions, that I hardly know which to specify; but I think, firstly, the newest points to me have been about the size of the brain in the three sexes, together with your suggestion that increase of mind-power may have led to the sterility of the workers.2 Secondly about the battles of the ants, & your curious account of the enraged ants being held by their comrades until they calmed down.3 Thirdly the evidence of ants of the same community being the offspring of brothers & sisters.4 You admit, I think, that new communities will often be the product of a cross between not-related ants. Fritz Müller has made some interesting observations on this head with respect to Termites.5 The case of of Anergates is most perplexing in many ways; but I have such faith in the law of occasional crossing that I believe an explanation will hereafter be found, such as the dimorphism of either sex & the occasional production of winged males.6 I see that you are puzzled how ants of the same community recognize each other; I once placed two ants (F. rufa) in a pill-box smelling strongly of assafœtida, & after a day returned them to their homes; they were threatened, but at last recognized. I made this trial thinking that they might know each other by their odour; but this cannot here have been the case, & I have often fancied that they must have some common signal.7 Your last chapter is one great mass of wonderful facts & suggestions, & the whole profoundly interesting. I have seldom been more gratified than by the honorable mention of my work

I should like to tell you one little observation which I made with care many years ago; I saw ants (Formica rufa) carrying coccoons from a nest which was the largest I ever saw & which was well known to all the country people near, & an old man apparently about 80 years of age told me that he had known it ever since he was a little boy. The ants carrying the coccoons did not appear to be emigrating; following the line I saw many ascending a tall fir tree still carrying their coccoons. But when I looked closely, I found that all the coccoons were empty cases. This astonished me, & next day I got a man to observe with me, & we again saw ants bringing empty coccoons out of the nest; each of us fixed on one ant & slowly followed it, & repeated the observation on many others. We thus found that some ants soon dropped their empty coccoons; others carried them for many yards, as much as 30 paces, & others carried them high up the fir tree out of sight.8 Now here I think we have one instinct in contest with another & mistaken one. The first instinct being to carry the empty coccoons out of the nest, & it would have been sufficient to have laid them on the heap of rubbish, as the first breath of wind would have blown them away. And then came in the contest with the other very powerful instinct of preserving & carrying their coccoons as long as possible; & this they could not help doing although the coccoons were empty. According as the one or other instinct was the stronger in each individual ant, so did it carry the empty coccoon to a greater or less distance. If this little observation should ever prove of any use to you, you are quite at liberty to use it.

Again thanking you cordially for the great pleasure which your Work has given me, I remain with much respect— Yours sincerely | Charles Darwin

P.S | If you read English easily I should like to send you Mr Belt’s book, as I think you would like it as much as did Fritz Müller9


CD refers to Les fourmis de la Suisse (Ants of Switzerland; Forel 1874); see letter from Auguste Forel, 23 September 1874. CD’s heavily annotated copy of Forel 1874 is in the Darwin Library–CUL (see Marginalia 1: 237–40).
Forel had observed that the mushroom bodies in workers (non-reproductive female) of the genus Formica, thought to be the most intelligent ants, were very large. The same parts were smaller in reproductive females and much smaller in males (Forel 1874, p. 123). CD scored the section in his copy and added a note (see Marginalia 1: 238). Mushroom bodies are the section of the brain in ants and other Hymenoptera associated with complex behaviour.
Forel observed amazon-ants, in a state he described as rage, killing everything in sight until slaves from their colony calmed them (Forel 1874, p. 304).
See n. 6, below.
In the first part of his study of termites (F. Müller 1873–5, pp. 333–9), Müller had described two sexual forms of both male and female termites in a newly discovered species Calotermes canellae (now Glyptotermes canellae); see letter to Fritz Müller, 1 January 1874 and n. 3. In the third part (F. Müller 1873–5, pp. 451–63), Müller argued that the existence of two forms of sexual reproduction in termites could be seen as confirmation of CD’s theory that crossing of individuals not closely related was beneficial or even necessary to the species; see letter from Fritz Müller, [c. January 1874] and n. 7.
Forel observed that the species Anergates atratulus (the dark guest ant), which was a parasite of Tetramorium caespitum, was devoid of workers and that there were no winged males, and concluded that all mating was between brothers and sisters, noting that any winged females that entered a nest already occupied by other A. atratulus would be killed by the workers of T. caespitum (Forel 1874, pp. 343–4).
Formica rufa is the red wood ant. CD mentioned the experiment in an undated note in DAR 205.11 (2): 106. The note refers to Moor Park, Farnham, Surrey, where CD stayed in 1857, 1858, and 1859. CD recounted the experiment in Variation 2: 251.
CD refers to observations of Formica rufa made during his stay at Moor Park in July 1859. His note describing this case, headed ‘July 23/59/’ and marked ‘Mistaken Instinct’, is in DAR 205.11 (2): 96.
CD had recommended Thomas Belt’s book The naturalist in Nicaragua (Belt 1874) in his letter to Forel of 28 September [1874]. He had sent a copy of the book to Fritz Müller in January 1874 (see letter to Fritz Müller, 1 January 1874). See also letter from Fritz Müller, 20 April [1874].


Forel, Auguste. 1874. Les fourmis de la Suisse. Zurich: Zurcher & Furrer. [Neue Denkschriften allgemeinen schweizerischen Gesellschaft für die gesammten Naturwissenschaften / Nouveaux mémoires de la Société helvétique des sciences vol. 26.]

Marginalia: Charles Darwin’s marginalia. Edited by Mario A. Di Gregorio with the assistance of Nicholas W. Gill. Vol. 1. New York and London: Garland Publishing. 1990.

Müller, Fritz. 1873–5. Beiträge zur Kenntniss der Termiten. I. Die Geschlechtstheile der Soldaten von Calotermes. II. Die Wohnungen unserer Termiten. III. Die ‘Nymphen mit kurzen Flügelscheiden’ (Hagen), ‘nymphes de la deuxième forme’ (Lespès). Ein Sultan in seinem Harem. IV. Die Larven von Calotermes rugosus Hag. Jenaische Zeitschrift für Naturwissenschaft 7 (1871–3): 333–58, 451–63; 9 (1875): 241–64.

Variation: The variation of animals and plants under domestication. By Charles Darwin. 2 vols. London: John Murray. 1868.


Writes about AHF’s book on Swiss ants.

Recounts his own observations on ants carrying cocoons.

Letter details

Letter no.
Charles Robert Darwin
Auguste-Henri (Auguste) Forel
Sent from
Source of text
Universität Zürich, Archiv für Medizingeschichte (AfM ZH PN 31.2:793)
Physical description
LS 6pp

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 9680,” accessed on 22 July 2024,

Also published in The Correspondence of Charles Darwin, vol. 22