From Charles Lyell 22 October 1861
London
22 Oct. | 1861
My dear Darwin
The Swiss engineers said that they tunneled the ice barrier in the case of the valley of Bagnes because if once the water overflowed it would cause a debacle.1
Therefore I hold that ice could not have formed the blockages in Lochaber unless we can assume that in every case the water escaped over some ‘col’ either into a contiguous valley on the same watershed, or over into the eastern watershed—2
Whether the barrier be of ice or moraine-matter it cannot stand long eno’ at one level to allow a shelf to form if the water issues at the ice-dam or moraine-dam— On the other hand if you suppose a continual increase of ice or moraine at the lower end of each glacier-lake you would have an ever-varying depth of water.
There is only one way to get a permanent level & that is by the water over-flowing some “col” distinct from the lower or dammed-up extremity of the lake.
If you can cite any case in Lochaber where a shelf does not coincide with a “col” (did not Milne or some one say there was one?)3 I cannot comprehend how it is to be reconciled with the ice or glacier-lake theory— I therefore do not suppose the “cols” were land-straits 4 but the places where the lakes were drained when forced to flow the wrong way—
Please to return this note that I may send it to Mr Jamieson & see if he agrees—5
ever sinly yrs | Cha Lyell
Footnotes
Bibliography
Rudwick, Martin John Spencer. 1974. Darwin and Glen Roy: a ‘great failure’ in scientific method? Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 5 (1974–5): 97–185.
Summary
Ice could not have formed the blockages in Lochaber unless in every case the water escaped over some col into a contiguous valley on the same watershed, or into the eastern watershed. Supposes that the cols were not land-straits, but the places where the lakes were drained when forced to flow the wrong way.
Letter details
- Letter no.
- DCP-LETT-3294F
- From
- Charles Lyell, 1st baronet
- To
- Charles Robert Darwin
- Sent from
- London
- Source of text
- Natural History Museum, Library and Archives (General Special Collections DC AL 7/1)
- Physical description
- ALS 4pp
Please cite as
Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 3294F,” accessed on 23 April 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-3294F.xml
Also published in The Correspondence of Charles Darwin, vol. 13 (Supplement)