skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

From J. F. McLennan   24 July 1877

Woodbury Cottage, | Biggin Hill, Norwood, S.E.

24 July 77

My dear Mr. Darwin,

In “The Descent of Man” you represent Sir George Grey as stating the proportion of women to men in Australia to be 1 : 3; & “others” as stating it to be 2 : 3; Also you refer to Azara (on Lubbock’s authority) as mentioning some tribe in South America as near extinction owing to the practice of female infanticide.1

These statements much interest me at present as I am making an induction of the facts as to systems of infanticide. Can you help me to your references? Where does Grey make his statement & who are the “others”; & who is Azara that I may consult him.2

I have not your book here, only a brief note I had made with a view to consult you. The only books of Grey’s I had in Algiers were his N. Western Travels (1st. Edition) & Polynesian Mythology & a small Australian Vocabulary.3 I searched in vain for any thing on female infanticide in him; but came on some figures pretending to show that in Australia fewer women were born than men by nearly as 2 : 3.

We were sorry not to be able to go to you on Saturday & also sorry to be so far from you & Hayes. We tried, without success, to get a cottage near Hayes or Down.4

The infanticide facts are very striking. If you have any to give me I will duly acknowledge the donor.

The Origin of Exogamy—ie of Laws of Incest—will I am sure much interest you.5 It leads, by sure signs, back to the brute state & so hooks man on to his “fellow creatures” by stronger links of evidence than have hitherto been forthcoming—apart from your general proposition of development I mean.

Give our best regards to Mrs. Darwin & the family. We are hoping to see Mr. & Mrs. Litchfield6 here someday soon. Just at present I regret to say Mrs. McLennan is an invalid;7 I am by comparison the strong one though nowise good for much.

Yrs. very sincerely | J. F McLennan.

Dont answer this till it is absolutely convenient for you,—if it shd. ever so be.

CD annotations

Top of letter: ‘p 592’ pencil circled pencil

Footnotes

See Descent 2d ed., p. 592. CD cited Félix d’Azara and mentioned John Lubbock’s views on the same page.
CD’s reply has not been found, but see the letter from J. F. McLennan, 30 July 1877. In Grey 1841, 2: 251 (Journals of two expeditions of discovery in north-west and western Australia), Grey wrote that in a sample taken by himself of 222 births, there was 1 female to every 1.3 males. CD also referred to Azara 1809, 2: 116 (Voyages dans l’Amérique méridionale).
Grey 1855 (Polynesian mythology) and 1840 (A vocabulary of the dialects of South Western Australia).
Hayes is about four miles from Down.
On exogamy (a term coined by McLennan), see McLennan 1865, pp. 48–9; see also letter from L. H. Morgan, 26 June 1877 and n. 13.
Richard Buckley Litchfield and Henrietta Emma Litchfield, CD’s son-in-law and daughter.

Bibliography

Azara, Félix de. 1809. Voyages dans l’Amérique Méridionale. Edited by C. A. Walckenaer, with additional notes by G. Cuvier. 4 vols. and atlas. Paris: Dentu.

Descent 2d ed.: The descent of man, and selection in relation to sex. By Charles Darwin. 2d edition. London: John Murray. 1874.

Grey, George. 1841. Journals of two expeditions of discovery in north-west and western Australia, during the years 1837, 38, and 39. 2 vols. London: T. and W. Boone.

Grey, George. 1855. Polynesian mythology and ancient traditional history of the New Zealand race, as furnished by their priests and chiefs. London: John Murray.

McLennan, John Ferguson. 1865. Primitive marriage: an inquiry into the origin of the form of capture in marriage ceremonies. Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black.

Summary

Asks for details on CD’s Descent references to female infanticide.

JFM’s work on the laws of incest finds strong evidence for man’s relation to animals.

Letter details

Letter no.
DCP-LETT-11069
From
John Ferguson McLennan
To
Charles Robert Darwin
Sent from
Norwood
Source of text
DAR 171: 24
Physical description
ALS 4pp †

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 11069,” accessed on 23 April 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-11069.xml

letter