To J. V. Carus 17 February 
Down. | Bromley. | Kent. S.E.
My dear Sir
I have read your Preface with care.1 It seems to me that you have treated Bronn with complete respect & great delicacy, & that you have alluded to your own labour with much modesty. I do not think that any of Bronn’s friends can complain of what you say & what you have done. For my own sake I grieve that you have not added notes, as I am sure that I should have profited much by them; but as you have omitted Bronn’s objections, I believe that you have acted with excellent judgment & fairness in leaving the text without comment to the independent verdict of the reader.2 I heartily congratulate you that the main part of your labour is over: it would have been to most men a very troublesome task, but you seem to have indomitable powers of work, judging from those two wonderful & most useful volumes on zoological literature, edited by you, & which I never open without surprise at their accuracy & gratitude for their usefulness.—3 I cannot sufficiently tell you how much I rejoice that you were persuaded to superintend the translation of the present edition of my book, for I have now the great satisfaction of knowing that the German public can judge fairly of its merits & demerits.—4
I have written to Dr. Carpenter for a specimen of the Eozoon & I hear from Mrs. Carpenter that he is out of London, but she thinks he will be able & will have great pleasure in sending you a specimen.5
When I receive it, I will send it by post if not too heavy; but if too heavy by the Booksellers Messrs. Williams & Norgate.
with my cordial & sincere thanks, believe me | My dear Sir | Yours very faithfully | Ch. Darwin
CD thinks JVC’s preface is fair to Bronn. Regrets JVC has not added notes of his own, but, having dropped Bronn’s appendix, it is perhaps best to leave the text without comment. Rejoices that the German public can now judge the Origin fairly.
Has written to W. B. Carpenter for a specimen of Eozoon to send to JVC.
- Letter no.
- Darwin, C. R.
- Carus, J. V.
- Sent from
- London, Queen Anne St, 6 Down letterhead
- Source of text
- Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin, Sammlung Darmstaedter (Carus 3)
- Physical description
Please cite as
Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 5403,” accessed on 24 January 2017, http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/DCP-LETT-5403