From J. D. Hooker 29 November 1879
Royal Gardens Kew
I have not yet thanked you for the Life of your Grandfather; which is not only very instructive but “great fun”, without a trace of buffoonery.— I was rather disappointed with Krause’s part, by contrast no doubt; for it shows a remarkable appreciation of Erasmus’s work, & this in many ways— altogether it is a very valuable little contribution to the History of Science in England.
We are “toiling & moiling” on here as usual, & overwhelmed with drudgery—
We had a horrid scare 10 days ago, in the form of a Telegram from “Nature” to Dyer to the effect that A Gray was dead, & asking for a biograph. notice. I could not but feel sure that one of his colleagues would have telegraphed to me, & yet was most anxious till 2 days ago, when I got a letter from him in excellent spirits. We still are thinking over our conjoint work on the Geograph distrib: of American Flora. I have sent him a comparison between the Rocky Mt. Flora & that of Altai, which present many curious points of affinity: as in variety or absence of Oaks, Nuts, & other Cupulifera which abound all round both areas. He now wants my Lecture to R. I. in a modified form, & a comparison of the European & Asiatic Floras, which might be very interesting in reference to America. I have a notion that the E Asiatic & W. European temperate & subtropical Floras are very distinct, but not so distinct as both are from the intermediate area—& that the Himalaya is the bridge between them, crossing the intermediate area.
Further the Himalaya contains a mingling of European types with others typical of both Eastern & Western America.
I commenced this intending to confine it to thanks for your book & the information that we have no cotton seeds— Shall I write to Egypt for some?.
Ever affy yrs | J D Hooker.
Congratulations on Erasmus Darwin; likes CD’s part better than Ernst Krause’s.
Received false notice of Asa Gray’s death.
Gray and JDH engaged in comparing widely separated but floristically similar regions.
Please cite as
Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 12336,” accessed on 12 February 2016, http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/DCP-LETT-12336