skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

From Francis Darwin   29 May 1879

Bot. Institut | Würzburg

May 29/79

My dear Father,

Stahl knows about the growth on A. pectinata; & I think the thing you saw must certainly be it: he says if you sent 2 or 3 leaves or a tiny twig in a letter he could tell at once as the fungus grows all through the leaves: it is an Æcidium; I will find out whether there is anything to be read about it.1 De Bary has written about it but I think only about the fungus part of it:2

The Porliera in the bed is rather unhappy looking but there are two pot plants in good state & I will look to the leafstalk.3 I have got 5 or 6 Anthurium & Aroids which are put between double windows with a big tin pan filling up the whole bottom & filled with water, & if the weather only gets hot they will sprout—but they have been wretchedly cared for & are unhealthy; the gardener is very bad—4 Stahl ⁠⟨⁠sheet missing⁠⟩⁠5

the houses hospitals. I shall have plenty for the caustic experiments after I have measured them   Sachs seems interested by the caustic stopping Geotropism.6 Sachs seems to have completely changed his ideas about the cause of heliotropism & quite given up the idea that it is merely the shaded side growing quicker: he spoke as if these experiments of mine were hardly worth doing because it was so certain that the heliotropism does not depend on the mere difference of light on the two sides. He has lent me Wiesner’s big paper on Heliotropism 69 pp 4to—‘Heliotropische Erscheinungen in Pflanzenreiche’, from the XXXIX Bd of the Vienna Denkschriften 1878   it can be bought.7 I will read it any how; Sachs doesn’t think much of it partly because it is all done by gas light. I will see what Sachs says in his last edition8   I was quite staggered when he spoke of “the old fashioned view of heliotropism which Wiesner still holds”

Stahl told me a little about A. B. Frank. He says he has a great respect for him & admires his work & especially likes his way of looking at the use things are to plants & not simply considering them as machines with epinasty &c like so may springs pressing them in various directions   Frank is about 40 & still a Docent, & has probably lost all chance of being a professor.9 He had a great dispute with Hofmeister in which he was impertinent to Hofmeister, he has also been squashed by Sachs & this has thrown him out in the struggle for life.10 The other night I went to see an Englishman named Thorne11 who is lecture-assistant in the Chemical Laboratory— I went to have a lesson in the spectroscope, I had a good go at Potash & I think I shall do some drop experiments here; Sachs wont hear of it being a secretion but says it comes out a gland bearing leaf because it increases the surface & gives a delicate surface &c &c which strikes me as bosh but I dont know how to disprove it. Sachs admired my little spectroscope so much I have had to order one for him. I have been doing interesting microscoping Chara, Marchantia, Vaucheria & various funguses.12 I went out to dinner at a Herr Merkens13 but it was wearisomely long— we waited for a man 12 an hour to start with till 8 o’clock, & then after dinner sat in big circle till past 12, no one could get up & go because Sachs didn’t.

I have had very nice letters from Mother & Bessy & I will write to them: I will keep or send G’s letter. Give Ubbadubba my love & say I should a letter in bool & red [picus]. I am glad to hear that he doesn’t let Ubbady get into mischief.14 I have been cultivating Mucor spores in drops of sugary water hanging under a cover glass; they send out a long one-celled tube which grows very quick15   I have been trying to see nutation in the plane of the glass; but the floor of the laboratory shakes too much for good observations, so that the growing tip is quite jogged away from the micrometer scale. Elving the Finn knows all about pollen tube growing16   I will try whether they are negatively heliotropic

Good by dear Father | Your affec | FD

CD annotations

2.1 The Porliera … Stahl 2.5] crossed pencil
3.1 Stahl … negatively heliotropic 4.9] crossed pencil
3.2 especially … plants] pencil cross in margin
3.3 like so may … 40 3.4] pencil cross in margin

Footnotes

See letter to Francis Darwin, [before 29 May 1879]. Ernst Stahl had been an assistant of Julius Sachs at Würzburg from 1874 until 1877 (NDB). Abies pectinata is a synonym of A. alba, the silver fir. Aecidium is a widespread genus of rust fungi.
Anton de Bary had published a paper ‘Ueber den Krebs und die Hexenbesen der Weisstanne (Abies pectinata DC.)’ (On the canker and witches’ brooms of the silver fir (Abies pectinata DC.); Bary 1867), in which he characterised the fungus infecting silver firs and also described the affected parts of the tree as the disease progressed.
In the summer of 1878, Francis had observed plants identified as Porliera hygrometrica at Würzburg; he recorded the movements of two specimens, one in the garden, the other in a pot. CD had also observed the movement in a specimen thought to be the same species, but which behaved differently. In taxonomic literature, Porliera is considered an incorrect subsequent spelling of Porlieria; the name Porlieria hygrometrica is unresolved, but is likely to be an error for P. hygrometra; the name was sometimes applied to specimens later identified as P. chilensis (see, for example, Johnston 1938, pp. 253–4). Based on Francis’s comparison of the Würzburg plants with a twig of the plant CD had received from Kew, the German plants were probably P. chilensis while CD’s specimen was P. hygrometra (see Correspondence vol. 26, letter from Francis Darwin, [after 7 July 1878] and n. 3).
Anthurium is the genus of laceleafs in the family Araceae (arums); aroid is a colloquial term referring to plants in this family. The gardener has not been identified.
Francis evidently failed to send one manuscript sheet of his letter, as CD noted in his reply of 2 June [1879].
CD had recently begun to study the effects of applying lunar caustic (silver nitrate) to the tips of radicles (embryonic roots) as part of a series of experiments investigating the sensitivity of the root apex that he had begun the previous year (see, for example, Correspondence vol. 26, letter to W. T. Thiselton-Dyer, 9 May [1878]).
The first part of Julius Wiesner’s monograph on heliotropic phenomena in plants (Wiesner 1878–80) appeared in Denkschriften der kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften, mathematisch-naturwissenschaftliche Classe. CD had read an abstract of the work the previous summer in Anzeiger der Kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften in Wien 15 (1878): 137–40 (see Correspondence vol. 26, letter to Francis Darwin, 17 July [1878] and n. 5). CD’s offprint of Wiesner 1878–80 is in the Darwin Library–CUL.
In the most recent edition of Sachs’s textbook of botany (Sachs 1874, p. 727), Sachs had noted that only higher wavelengths of light produced bending and slowed growth. Wiesner had reported that all wavelengths except yellow produced heliotropism (Wiesner 1878–80, p. 190).
Albert Bernhard Frank had, in fact, become a professor extraordinarius of botany at Leipzig in 1878. Frank had originated the concept of symbiosis (Symbiotismus) in his 1876 paper on crustose lichens (see Frank 1876, pp. 196–7). On the term epinasty, see the letter from Hugo de Vries, 24 February 1879, n. 3.
Wilhelm Hofmeister and Frank had disagreed about the nature of heliotropism and geotropism in articles published in Botanische Zeitung between April and June 1868. Frank had argued against Hofmeister’s explanation of these phenomena in his book Beiträge zur Pflanzenphysiologie (Contributions to plant physiology; Frank 1868).
Chara is a genus of stoneworts (an order of green algae); Marchantia is a genus of liverworts; Vaucheria is a genus of yellow-green algae.
Herr Merkens has not been identified.
None of the letters from Emma Darwin, Elizabeth Darwin, or George Howard Darwin have been found. Ubbadubba was a pet name for Francis’s son Bernard Darwin; Ubbady was Bernard’s name for Elizabeth Darwin (see F. Darwin 1920b, p. 46). ‘Bool and red [picus]’ was probably Bernard’s mispronunciation of ‘blue and red pictures’.
Mucor is a genus of filamentous fungi; sporangia in species of this genus are typically spherical with well-developed columellae.
Fredrik Elfving was a student in Sachs’s laboratory. Following adhesion of a pollen grain to the stigma, the grain exserts a tube through which sperm cells are delivered to the ovule. The formation of tubes can be artificially induced with acid (see Fritzsche 1832, p. 2).

Bibliography

Bary, Anton de. 1867. Ueber den Krebs und die Hexenbesen der Weisstanne (Abies pectinata DC.). Botanische Zeitung 25: 257–64.

Darwin, Francis. 1920b. The story of a childhood. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd.

Frank, Albert Bernhard. 1868. Beiträge zur Pflanzenphysiologie. Leipzig: Wilhelm Engelmann.

Frank, Albert Bernhard. 1876. Ueber die biologischen Verhältnisse des Thallus einiger Krustenflechten. Beiträge zur Biologie der Pflanzen 2 (1876–7): 123–97.

Fritzsche, Julius. 1832. Beiträge zur Kenntniss des Pollen. Vol. 1. Berlin, Stettin, and Elbing: Nicolai’schen Buchhandlung.

Johnston, Ivan M. 1938. New or noteworthy plants from temperate South America. Journal of the Arnold Arboretum 19: 248–63.

NDB: Neue deutsche Biographie. Under the auspices of the Historical Commission of the Bavarian Academy of Sciences. 27 vols. (A–Wettiner) to date. Berlin: Duncker & Humblot. 1953–.

Sachs, Julius. 1874b. Lehrbuch der Botanik nach dem gegenwärtigen Stand der Wissenschaft. 4th edition. Leipzig: W. Engelmann.

Wiesner, Julius. 1878–80. Die heliotropischen Erscheinungen im Pflanzenreiche. [Read 4 July 1878 and 18 March 1880.] Denkschriften der kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften, mathematisch-naturwissenschaftliche Classe 39 (1879) pt. 1: 143–209; 42 (1880) pt. 1: 1–92.

Summary

Fungus is an Aecidium. Porliera, Anthuriums and Aroids will hopefully sprout if weather gets hot. Sachs has changed his ideas about the cause of heliotropism. Describes men he is sharing a lab with.

Letter details

Letter no.
DCP-LETT-12067F
From
Francis Darwin
To
Charles Robert Darwin
Sent from
Würzburg
Source of text
DAR 274.1: 54
Physical description
ALS inc

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 12067F,” accessed on 23 April 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-12067F.xml

letter