From W. T. Goodale 11 February 1874
Bowdoin College | Brunswick Maine USA
Feb 11. 1874
My Dear Sir,
Will you pardon a Student for coming to you for information on a point which perplexes him?
I have lately been reading Dr. Hopkin’s “Outline Study of Man”.1 In the book he takes a Stand against the development theory.
Looking at Man as made up of several systems, the digestive, circulatory, respiratory, secretory, absorbent, osseous &c. he says of the osseous “xx each bone of the Skeleton is formed from a distinct center of ossification, is formed as a distinct instrument, in most cases tipped with cartilage, & except through this cartilage never comes into contact with any other bone. The bones of the upper extremity are a separate organization that do not touch except at a single point those of the lower. Indeed each bone seems to have been formed separately, as a mechanic forms nails, & pegs & the different portions of a chair & then brings them together. There is nothing to indicate that they start from a common centre “xx” & if that be so when but a single system is concerned much more is it so in relation to the several systems. To me it does not seem possible that each & all of these can so exist in a single cell that their production can be at all accounted for by development. The process stands by itself *—both that of origination & growth, & is utterly inscrutable”2
I am somewhat perplexed by these statements & in my own mind cannot reconcile them to the development theory. Probably I have not sufficiently studied the matter, but I have seen nothing in the course of my reading on the Subject that covers it.
Is it asking too much of you to Enlighten me on it, or to direct me where I can find it explained? If you have not seen the work alluded to may I have the pleasure of sending you a copy? I should be much gratified to reciprocate the kindness you did me in forwarding your very valuable pamphlet on the “Habits & Movements of climbing plants.”3
Very truly your obed Servant | W. T. Goodale
Footnotes
Bibliography
‘Climbing plants’: On the movements and habits of climbing plants. By Charles Darwin. [Read 2 February 1865.] Journal of the Linnean Society (Botany) 9 (1867): 1–118.
Hopkins, Mark. 1873. An outline study of man; or, the body and mind in one system. New York: Scribner, Armstrong, & Company.
Summary
Asks CD if he can reconcile a passage in Mark Hopkins’ Outline study of man [1873] with the theory of development.
Letter details
- Letter no.
- DCP-LETT-9282
- From
- Walter Temple Goodale
- To
- Charles Robert Darwin
- Sent from
- Bowdoin College, Brunswick, Maine
- Source of text
- DAR 165: 72
- Physical description
- ALS 3pp
Please cite as
Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 9282,” accessed on 28 March 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-9282.xml
Also published in The Correspondence of Charles Darwin, vol. 22