skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

To G. J. Romanes   6 January 1882

Down, | Beckenham, Kent. | (Railway Station | Orpington. S.E.R.)

Jan 6th 1882

My dear Romanes

I had no intention to trouble you about preparing the paper, but you seem to be quite untirable & I am glad to shirk any extra labour. It is shabby of me, but I gladly accept your offer to prepare a paper for Linn. Soc. if you think fit, & an abstract for Nature. I can thus send copies to the Baron & Dr. Glass.— By the way I cannot remember which of the two started the plan so this must be left in the dark.— As it wd appear so odd the sending of a document signed & stamped without some explanation, I think it is quite necessary that the paper shd. be presented with some such statement as I have written down.1

As it can do no harm I have scribbled down the headings of the sort of paper which I shd. have made, had I not shabbily allowed you to undertake the task.2

I quite agree about the Microscope & Grant Allen3

Yours very sincerely | Ch. Darwin

[Enclosure]

Mr. Darwin received, as he informs me, about two years ago a letter from the Baron de Villa Franca in Brazil, stating that he had raised new varieties of the Sugar-Cane by planting distinct varieties in apposition. As far as Mr Darwin can remember he expressed in answer his doubts whether the growth in close apposition of two varieties could possibly affect the character of the buds produced by either variety; & he thought it more probable that the new variety was due to bud-variation, which might be favoured by the conditions to which the cuttings had been subjected & is in itself an interesting fact.4 Recently he has received through the Brazilian Legation a letter from the Baron, enclosing one from Dr Glass, Superintendent of the Bot. Garden at Rio de Janeiro, in which he minutely describes the process adopted, a translation of which will be immediately given. The Baron also encloses a statement by eight land-owners & distinguished men in Brazil, made before a public notary, testifying to the fact that new & valuable varieties have been raised by this process.5 The subject is interesting because so few cases &c &c

Enlarge a little on physiological importance.—

Potatoes

Hyacinth

Blotched trees &c

Vines

Dr G. describes in detail with diagrams his attempts at first to graft together 2 varieties of the Sugar-cane & that he always failed, notwithstanding that he succeeded with another Monocotyledon, viz Dracaena—

Then Translation

Then Summary of the notices drawn up before the public Notary.—

(Then a brief Summary of the whole)

Perhaps a short discussion on the physiological importance of case wd. come in here best; but it is on the other hand advantageous to attract reader’s attention early in the day—

Would it not be adviseable to express a hope that Dr. Glass would describe minutely the differences between the 2 joined varieties & the detailed character of the consequent new form?

The increased vigour of the new varieties thus raised, like cross-fertilised vars., deserves notice.—

Footnotes

The letter to which this is a reply has not been found; see, however, the letter to G. J. Romanes, 1 January [1882]. CD had received documents on the production of new varieties of sugar cane from Ignacio Francisco Silveira da Motta, baron de Vila Franca (see Correspondence vol. 29, letter from Arthur de Souza Corrêa, 28 December 1881). ‘Dr Glass’ was Auguste François Marie Glaziou. From these documents, CD and Romanes prepared a paper, ‘On new varieties of the sugar-cane produced by planting in apposition’, which was sent to the Linnean Society of London on 6 April 1882; it was read on 4 May 1882, but not published (Proceedings of the Linnean Society of London (1880–2): 30–1; Linnean Society, SP register, reference 2371). According to the Proceedings, the paper was ‘Communicated by the late Charles Darwin’. No copy of the paper has been found.
For CD’s outline of the proposed paper, see the enclosure.
CD had suggested giving Grant Allen a microscope (see Correspondence vol. 29, letter to G. J. Romanes, 8 December 1881).
The statement from the Brazilian landowners has not been found.

Summary

Accepts GJR’s offer to prepare sugar-cane paper for publication [Villa Franca and Glass, "New varieties of sugar-cane", Proc. Linn. Soc. Lond. (1880–2): 30–1]. Suggests introduction and outline.

Agrees with GJR on microscope for Grant Allen.

Letter details

Letter no.
DCP-LETT-13600
From
Charles Robert Darwin
To
George John Romanes
Sent from
Down
Source of text
American Philosophical Society (Mss.B.D25.611), DAR 207: 4
Physical description
ALS 3pp encl 2pp

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 13600,” accessed on 19 April 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-13600.xml

letter